In Ukraine, there is an ongoing discussion about how exactly to sell scrap metal for export. The Ministry of Economy proposes to launch an auction mechanism for this purpose, but the department is criticized for the proposed mechanism. In particular, expert Andriy Zablovskyi said that scrap should be sold exclusively through open electronic auctions, and the rules should be the same for all market participants.
According to him, any preferences, closed procedures or exceptions for individual state companies during the sale of strategic raw materials destroy competition and create unequal conditions. "Scrap should be sold exclusively through open, transparent electronic auctions at market prices for all participants without exception," he emphasized. Competitive auctions, in his opinion, make it possible to obtain the maximum price for lots and increase revenues to the budget.
The starting price determines who will earn
Critics draw attention to the starting price of the quota. The Ministry of Economy is currently discussing 27 euros per ton. According to GMK Center calculations, for this price, the budget will receive only 5.4 million euros, and the excess profit of traders will increase almost three times - to 17.2 million euros.
If the starting price is 80 euros per ton, the budget can receive about 16 million euros, and the excess profit of exporters will be about 6.6 million euros.
Protection of the internal market
Separately, Zablovsky drew attention to the shortage of raw materials for Ukrainian metallurgy. According to him, the uncontrolled export of scrap has traditionally created risks for the domestic market, so the export duty should remain a tool to protect domestic consumption. In the conditions of war, this issue is especially important: metallurgical enterprises work under shelling, save jobs and pay taxes.
Among the key decisions, the expert named the legislative synchronization of the rules for the sale of scrap by state and communal enterprises through public auctions. Also, in his opinion, it is necessary to preserve the balance between export and domestic consumption and to stimulate the development of the domestic scrap procurement market. "Transparent rules, the same conditions for all participants and controlled exports will simultaneously support the budget, the domestic scrap market and the future recovery of Ukrainian metallurgy," he concluded.